Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 

He Didn't Love Her by ~RedGyl:iconRedGyl:



I'm crying.

I'm not crying because Zutara didn't happen. I'm not even crying because Kataang happened.

I'm crying because Kataang happened just because.

Aang showed more love, attention and affection for Appa than he did for Katara.

Since "the Fortuneteller" in Season 1 when Aang first discovers that he has a crush on Katara, what has Aang done for her? He returned her necklace to her. He invited her to dance with him. What else? Please, tell me, what else?

He forced himself onto her several times, never listening to her feelings.

He was mean to her, broke promises to her, and stopped apologizing to her. He put her in danger, threw fits that endangered her, and didn't say sorry.

Sokka made a sand sculpture of his love, Suki. Aang made a sand sculpture of his love, Appa.

For someone who supposedly loved a woman, Aang seldom ever thought of her, let alone took care of her, or showed any affection for her. He treated her as nothing more than another friend.

I'm crying. Aang didn't really love Katara!! If he did, he would've been tender with her like he was with Appa and Momo, like Sokka was with Suki. He would have considered her needs and wants. He would have looked out for her, tried to protect her and keep her safe. He would have listened to her when she was telling him something he didn't want to hear.

If Aang loved Katara, he would've done more than just treat her like the rest of the Gaang. He would have been getting her flowers, shared his culture with her by making her a little Air Nomad treat, asked her to share some of her culture with him, thanked her for doing all of the cooking for everyone, tried to make breakfast for everyone so she wouldn't have to, thanked her for always being so kind and caring, told her she was beautiful, said he was concerned for her father when he was taken captive, praised her in front of others, defended her when her good character was attacked, given her rides through the sky on his glider just so she could laugh and feel young again. He could have done any of those things and others in any and all of the episodes! He could have treated her as more than a friend!

In "The Southern Raiders," Aang could have expressed concern for Katara's safety and well being. He didn't have to condone her actions, but he could have threatened Zuko to watch over Katara, saying that if she comes back harmed in any way, that the Fire Prince would face the Avatar's Severe Displeasure. And when Katara did come back, he could have said, "are you all right? I'm so glad you're safe, I was worried about you." Instead, he lectures her, acting like he knows better than her because he couldn't stand the idea that the Love Of His Life was human enough to feel hatred.

In "The Ember Island Players," he could have expressed displeasure in the choice of actress for Katara. He could have said, "Hey! That woman's not pretty enough to be Katara! This show stinks," or something like that. He could have NOT forced that kiss on Katara. And even after he did, he could have approached her  later to say, "I'm so sorry. I shouldn't have done that. Please forgive me." Instead, he only pouts about the Actress-Aang and does nothing to try to make things right between himself and Katara.

In the first episode of the finale, did Aang so much as say "thank you," to Katara for getting him some watermelon juice? I don't remember. And it was OK that he made the sand sculpture of Appa, but was there a little figure of Katara riding on Appa's back?

Aang hasn't been treating Katara right. Why would she love him? Is she really that pathetic? Is she so insignificant, so small and insecure and shallow, that she would fall in love with an immature brat who cared more about his animals than he did for her, who neglected her and took her for granted? Is Katara really nothing more than a pawn in the "shipping war," a prize to be given at will to whomever the writers feel like? Is Katara -- the strong, passionate, caring, deep girl who had the maturity of a full-grown woman, who wouldn't stand for any sexist behavior from her brother or from her waterbending teacher -- really so pitiful? Of so little worth?

This is just too wrong. If Aang had done ANYTHING, ANYTHING recently to show Katara affection, attention ... anything to show her how much he valued her, how much he respected and treasured her ... I would have been okay with her falling in love with him. But this ... I can't support this. I can't let my little children watch this. I don't want my daughters or my sons to watch this and think that girls are just pawns, just little prizes to be given away to the hero just because he's the title character. I don't want my sons or daughters to think that if they obsess over someone else, that someone else is now a toy ogligated to give them what they want. There are enough real-life heartaches and broken families in the world as it is without letting my children watch such lies as entertainment.

I am not buying anything more Avatar related. I just won't.
©2008-2009 ~RedGyl
:iconredgyl:

Author's Comments

All things "Avatar" The Last Airbender" related belong to Mike and Bryan and Viacom and Nickolodeon, etc etc etc. Am I EVER so glad I have nothing to do with them.

This is not a kind piece. If your world revolves around Kataang, please read this and understand. You can disagree with me, but please don't disagree with your eyes shut, blindly saying that anything Bryke does with their work is AOK. It's not. They may have all creative rights to do what they want with their story, but I don't have to support them any further in it.


EDIT: I do not hate Aang. He's just a child, and I cannot expect him to be able to handle a romantic relationship yet. I do not hold his social clumsiness against him. I sincerely hope for nothing but the best for him. My issue is with Mike and Bryan for what they did to Katara.

So, yeah, my essay is a bit harsh, but please understand that I love Aang! Really, I do! It's the creators that I am angry at. Aang couldn't make Katara love him, but Bryke sure could!

EDIT #2: For those who think I'm being unfair to Kataang, read this: [link]

For all ye who think that the best way to defend Kataang is to attack Zutara, go here: [link]

For all ye who say I'm overreacting, I'll quote Bill Harley: "Stories are a model to begin to understand your life and discover the truth. The story is not the truth, but the way we approach the truth." For example, from Cinderella we learn that bad things happen to good people, resolution is rarely immediate, everyone needs dreams, and the ability to see good among the ills in life is priceless. This is why the fictional work of Cinderella is worth treasuring.

I apologize that I'm no longer able to reply to everyone like I've wanted to (hense why this second edit). I thank you all for your support and for your respectfiul disagreements, and know that I will at least read every comment. I wish you all well! Thank you!

Comments


:iconjazzjazz001:
Hm wow. You have a VERY good point here. I have to agree with you in your displeasure with the way Aang and Katara just hooked up because. It left a "What????" impression because as you pointed out, Aang hasn't really shown any affection for Katara since forever ago. I will even go as far to say that Aang is selfish for being the "humble monk" he is supposed to be. But we also have to remember he is just a boy. Even the previous avatars admit while on Giant Lion-Turtle Island that their indecision and avoidance brought terrible things to the world. So not only does Aang have a lot to go through as a kid but he's got the whole past lives making the same mistakes over and over working on him too.

But then we also have to remember that it doesn't end here. You can't give up on Aang as a character. He's still got a lot to learn. We still have book 4 maybe? (There were a lot of open questions. I'm going to hope that there will be more) And even if there isn't that doesn't mean Aang or Sokka will NEVER MATURE and turn into a respectable man. Zuko changes. Why won't Aang change too? I'm just saying it isn't all right to condemn a child, because thats what Aang still is. He also doesn't have someone in his life like your children do, to guide him through life. And I think thats where Aang is lost. (And the writers were a tad bit sexist) He deosn't really have a mother or a mother figure (where was she in all of this?) to tell him that hey thats not how you treat a girl or anything along that line. See you as a parent have already made the conscious decision to teach your children between right and wrong. Aang doesn't have that.

And to me, from my interpretation, it sounds like you have some personal experience with guys not treating women right. And it also makes it more difficult to watch Avatar: The Last Airbender. I understand. I'm just saying that you won't give up on your son or your daughter if they don't understand the righteous path no matter what. Kinda like what Zuko was going through. Aang doesn't have that person to root for him or coach him through life like Iroh or a mother or even a father. He's just kinda lost like Zuko was.

So to sum up: Aang=little child with no mentor. Result= the Avatar ending.
:iconredgyl:
Thank you for reading this, and for your well-thought-out reply.

Believe it or not, I adore Aang. I do believe he's doing the adsolute best he could with the cards life's handed him. I rooted for him to not surrender his ideals and kill Ozai. I loved his lightheartedness and how he changed and grew. I'm sorry if my essay is a bit harsh, but I'm not angry with Aang. Aang is just a kid! But I'm severely disappointed with the creators, especially with how they treated Katara.

--
"That lemur! It's earthbending!"
:iconkyokomari:
Dude, thank you. This is why I can't see Kataang. It took me all this time to realize what felt so completely and horribly off about it, and this is it. He just doesn't treat her right. He takes her motherly care, but never does anything for her with minimal exceptions. I actually saw it in EIP, but then none of that got resolved, so here we are. Here I am, I hate Aang and I hate how KAtaang happened.

(Notice that I said HOW it happened. If they'd tried to put some development somewhere in the finale, maybe I could see it, but they didn't. It just freakin HAPPENED.)

He never got fully developed(DAMNED if he's just a kid, he's still the main character) and he's still possessive, childish, and throws a stinkin' FIT when he thinks he can't have her. EIP proved it. And it made me get on the Aang-hate bandwagon. And I'm not moving since he hasn't really changed.

--
"It is heavily implied that you are beating the crap out of me!!" --Also YGOTAS

And never cast two birds in a glass house.
---

So...If Glitter is the Herpes of the craft supplies...Does that mean...

Edward Cullen has Herpes?
:iconjiko29:
I too, felt forced by that ending. Not rooting for one pairing over the other, but it seemed in the last few episodes there was A LOT of chemistry going on between Zuko and Katara, Aang hardly came off as even interested in Katara, and then suddenly: *gasp* Aang and Katara are suddenly "withit" WTF? was there some unknown veiwer poll that was taken to determine that? Or did the creators feel they JUST HAD to pair off everyone... except for poor Toph.

--
Well is a deep subject for shallow minds
:iconwoofie-chan:
i understand and im also sad. It came outta nowhere.... but im hoping so damned hoping they also made an alternate ending.. they better have (probably not but they better... *growls)

--
No touchie my kitty or those pretty fingers of your, along with the arms maybe [...] , come off. Oki? *innocent grin*

98% of the teenage population does or has tried smoking pot. If you're one of the 2% who hasn't, copy & paste this in your signature
:iconrukamousse:
I agree wholeheartedly, that Aang and Katara seemed as though they were miraculously shoved together in the end. I realized that Zuko still had feelings for Mei, he cared about her, but there was also the build-up and working toward gaining respect and friendship from Katara. Don't get me wrong though, it's not like I was sitting here rooting for Zutara anyway, I'm happy for the dude- but still.

Aang just waltzes back into the picture to claim his prize for saving the world? Are they only together because Katara is so enthralled that Aang was able to save everyone without the destruction of one man? Could the creators not of taken a little more time into the actual development of Katara and Aang? Then there wouldn't be this huge 'kerfuffle' around it.

I just don't really get it.

Also, though-- Jazz up there, has a fine point. Aang is what- 12? He has no guidance. He's just as dumb as any child trying to create a "mature relationship", as well has having no guidance. D: He's a good kid-- if not a little lost.

--
Anime is a 30-minute commercial, and we can sell it to Americans for LOTS of money. :'D
:icondragonjadefire:
I totally agree with you. I wouldn't be half as upset with kataang. With Maiko, Zuko actcually showed interest in Mai, I guess in her own way, should that she cared about him too. But Aang, Aang never showed anything towards Katara. True, he did try to give her a flower, but even after he saved the village he could've flown up to the volcane and grabbed a flower for her or picked on. But did he? no!
Zuko, even though he was with the gaang only for a while, still showed that he cared about Katara. Even in the Zutara Cave, he showed that he cared, becaue he apogized to her about hte lost of her mother. He felt guilty that his country his father took a young gilr's mother away from her. And then he went so far as to bring her to the man responisbile for the lost of her mother. If that's not love, I don't know what is! You are 100% correct in saying that the kataang relationship is a big sugar coated lie.
Even Katara showed taht she cared for Zuko! She offered to heal his scar with her spirit water (the important spirit water! The first person she offers to use it on is Zuko! Not Jet and not Aang! But zuko!). She even felt concern for him when he betrayed his uncle on stage, and when he was about to meet his uncle! Both Zuko and Katara had saved each others lives. Zuko saved Katara's life in the Southern Raiders, and Katara saved his life in the same episode and then again in the finale when he got hurt from Azul'as lightning.


And the sad thing is that the kataangers support it, , they don't see the lie that kataang is.

--
When the character of a man is not clear to you, look at his friends. - Japanese proverb

----
居住笑愛
:iconpaintedbluerose:
That right there is the truth. I hate Aang because of all of this. He shows no compassion towards her, yet he loves her? Yeah right. If he did, he would have saved her from the rocks falling down. If he did, he would have demanded to go with her on this epic journey of hers. If he did, he would have shown it. I don't think he did, did he? He just relied on her and her "magic water" to get him thru the day. Worhtless! Pathetic!

--
When I see you, I smile. When you talk, I'm speechless. When you walk, I stare. What can I say... retards amuse me. :)
--
You’re like our brother. :no: Step brother. :no: Weird kid down the street who eats nothing but mayonnaise on saltines. :nod:
:iconeskimobob2:
i don't know why your even arguing this it happend they wrote it its a fiction show and wrost of all u cried when katara and aang kissed... dude thats pathetic
:iconhalf-elf:
I agree with your point about Kataang. I still love Mike and Bryan, for giving us a great story, but I think that they sort of copped out with the romance. It was just "there". Katara was just given to the hero because he's the hero. I've never felt that Aang treated Katara like he loved her. Now, I'm a Zutarian, but regardless of that, I feel obligated to say that Zuko did more for Katara than Aang ever did. Aang called himself her friend, but lied to her. He put her well-being aside because he didn't wanna be separated from her. He put what he felt above what mattered to her. Zuko, at least, was willing to give his life to protect her. Not saying Zuko DID love her or anything, but I think that it's not right that even he did more than Aang, who in the end "gets the girl". I know it's just a story, and they can do what they want with it, but I think they didn't play that out properly so that it made sense.

--
"...Weeping may endure for a night, but joy cometh in the morning." --from Psalm 30:5

Let the Glory be God's!!
---------

"Be the kind of woman that when your feet hit the floor each morning the devil says, 'Oh crap, she's up'."

Details

July 21, 2008
5.3 KB

Statistics

539
168 [who?]
11,069 (0 today)
12 (0 today)

Site Map